Gemini vs Kraken: Which US Exchange in 2026?
Gemini vs Kraken compared on fees, regulation, staking, and security track record. See which US-regulated exchange fits security-focused holders.
Updated July 2026 · Reviewed by the PipeFlare team
Gemini vs Kraken is a matchup between two of the longest-running, most security-focused US exchanges. Gemini launched in 2014 under the Winklevoss twins as a New York State-chartered trust company, regulated directly by the NYDFS. Kraken launched in 2011 and holds one of the industry's cleanest security records — it has never suffered a major exchange-level hack. Both target security-conscious, US-compliant traders rather than the lowest-fee, widest-coin-list crowd. This guide compares fees, regulation, staking, and each exchange's track record.
Comparing Gemini and Kraken? Compare their sign-up bonuses before you fund a trading account.
Gemini vs Kraken at a glance
| Dimension | Gemini | Kraken |
|---|---|---|
| Best for | Security-focused US traders wanting a regulated trust company | Security-focused traders wanting deep markets and margin/futures |
| Trading fees | ActiveTrader tier from ~0.03-0.40% maker/taker by volume; basic app costs more | ~0.00-0.40% maker/taker on Kraken Pro by volume; basic app costs more |
| Regulatory status | New York State-chartered trust company, NYDFS-regulated | US money services business; state-by-state money transmitter licenses |
| Security track record | Insured hot wallet; underwent the 2022-2023 Genesis/Gemini Earn recovery process | No major exchange-level hack on record since 2011 launch |
| Staking & earn | In-app staking for select assets | Staking available; settled a 2023 SEC case over its US staking-as-a-service program |
| Coins listed | Hundreds of assets, curated selection | Hundreds of assets, one of the industry's broader listings |
| US availability | Available in most US states | Available in most US states |
Regulation and the Gemini Earn history
Gemini's core exchange has always operated as a NYDFS-regulated trust company, which comes with capital and custody requirements ordinary exchanges don't carry. Its now-discontinued Gemini Earn program — a separate lending product run in partnership with Genesis Global Capital — froze in November 2022 when Genesis's parent company filed for bankruptcy, leaving Earn users unable to withdraw for over a year. Gemini and the New York Attorney General reached settlements that returned funds to affected users, but it's a real event worth knowing if you're evaluating Gemini's track record. Gemini's core exchange and custody products were not directly implicated — the freeze was isolated to the separate lending program. Kraken has no comparable incident. It settled with the SEC in 2023 over its US staking-as-a-service offering, paying $30 million and ceasing that specific US program, but that's a regulatory-registration dispute rather than a loss of customer funds.
Fees and trading tools compared
Both exchanges follow the same pattern: their simple retail apps cost more per trade, while their professional tiers (Gemini ActiveTrader, Kraken Pro) offer volume-based maker/taker pricing that can drop well under 0.10% for active traders. Neither is the cheapest option in the market at the retail tier — that's generally Binance or Bybit — but both are competitive at the pro tier. Kraken additionally offers margin and futures trading through Kraken Pro, which Gemini does not match at the same depth. If derivatives access matters to you, that's a real differentiator in Kraken's favor.
Which fits security-conscious traders
Both exchanges court the same audience: US-based traders who weight regulatory compliance and security history over the absolute lowest fee. Gemini's NYDFS trust-company charter is a genuinely stronger regulatory structure than a typical money-transmitter license, though it applies to the exchange proper, not the discontinued Earn program. Kraken's selling point is a 14-plus-year track record with no major exchange-level breach, plus deeper margin and futures tools for active traders. A non-obvious tradeoff: Gemini's trust-company structure gives it stronger custodial requirements on paper, while Kraken's longer uninterrupted operating history is itself a form of evidence — both are legitimate, different ways of judging trust.
The verdict
Pick Gemini if you want the extra regulatory structure of a NYDFS-chartered trust company and a clean, simple app. Pick Kraken if you want deeper trading tools — margin and futures — plus a long, uninterrupted security track record. Know the Gemini Earn history before you judge Gemini's past by its core exchange's actual record.
Frequently asked questions
Is Gemini safer than Kraken?
Both are considered among the more security-focused US exchanges. Gemini is a NYDFS-regulated trust company with stronger custodial requirements on paper; its now-discontinued Gemini Earn lending program froze during the 2022 Genesis bankruptcy, though its core exchange was not directly implicated and affected users were later made whole through settlements. Kraken has no comparable freeze and has never suffered a major exchange-level hack since 2011.
What happened to Gemini Earn?
Gemini Earn was a separate lending product run with Genesis Global Capital, not Gemini's core exchange. It froze withdrawals in November 2022 when Genesis's parent company filed for bankruptcy. Gemini and the New York Attorney General later reached settlements that returned funds to affected users. Gemini's regular exchange and custody accounts were not part of the freeze.
Does Kraken have lower fees than Gemini?
At the retail app tier, fees are broadly similar and both cost more than the pro tiers. At the professional tier — Kraken Pro and Gemini ActiveTrader — both offer volume-based pricing that can fall well under 0.10% for active traders. Check each exchange's live fee schedule, since rates change by volume tier.
Can I trade futures on Gemini like I can on Kraken?
Kraken offers margin and futures trading through Kraken Pro at a depth Gemini does not match. Gemini focuses more on spot trading, custody, and its ActiveTrader tier. If derivatives access matters to you, Kraken is the stronger fit between the two.
Sources
Related guides
Ready to get started?
Compare regulated exchange sign-up bonuses — they pay you and a referrer after a qualifying trade.